home >issues >consumer protection >tenant landlord hotline >responsibilities

Tenant-Landlord Hotline
1-888-345-7474
-or-
mthotline@gmail.com




Landlord and Tenant Rights and Responsibilities


General Provisions

Montana law recognises that both tenants and landlords have an interest in maintaining the rental unit and that the tenant/landlord relationship is by nature a symbiotic one. Tenants need landlords to provide a place for them to live and without tenants, landlords would be deprived of a source of income. Correspondingly, tenants and landlords have responsibilities to one another. Generally, tenants have a responsibility to pay the landlord rent in a timely manner and to maintain and care for the landlords property ( MCA 70-24-201 , 70-24-321 ). Alternately, landlords have a responsibility to provide the tenant with a fit and habitable dwelling and to maintain the premises for which the tenant is paying ( MCA 70-24-302 , 70-24-303 ).

Providing a fit and habitable dwelling means that the rental unit must comply with local building codes affecting health and safety and must have at least basic amenities such as heating, hot and cold running water, electricity, proper plumbing, a smoke detector and adequate ventilation. Landlords must also maintain any and all appliances supplied as part of the rental agreement ( MCA 70-24-303 ). In addition, rules and regulations set forth by the landlord must be applied and enforced uniformly and fairly ( MCA 70-24-311 ).

The tenant has a corresponding responsibility to maintain the dwelling, as far as it is in their control, and to keep the unit safe and reasonably clean. Tenants must dispose of all waste in accordance with health and safety codes. The tenant may not destroy, deface, damage or remove any part of the premises and must use the areas within the dwelling unit as they are designed to be used. For instance, a kitchen may not be turned into a ceramics studio. Also, the tenant may not unduly harass or disturb neighbours or use the rental in such a way so as to interfere with neighbour's peaceable enjoyment of their premises ( MCA 70-24-321 ).


Maintenance of Premises and Property

Damages and Repairs

As stated above, the landlord must keep the premises in fit and habitable condition. The tenant has a corresponding obligation to treat the rental unit with care. If the tenant or a guest of the tenant accidentally or intentionally damages the rental property, the tenant is responsible for covering cost of repairs and/or replacement. Tenants must promptly notify the landlord of any damage to the unit.

Occasionally, repairs will be necessary through no fault of the tenant. Before asking the landlord to do repairs, tenants should make sure that: (1) the repairs are not for damages which are the tenants fault, and (2) the damages affect the fitness and habitability of the rental unit. If the tenant thinks the damages might pose a serious health or safety hazard, they should arrange for the county or city building inspector to examine the rental unit. The inspector will normally notify the owner, in writing, of any defects.

Tenants may never withhold rent to induce the landlord to perform repairs. Montana law recognizes that tenants need effective processes to ensure prompt repairs, but it draws a sharp distinction between these processes and prompt rent payment. Withholding rent in order to force repairs is improper; in response, the landlord can terminate the rental agreement on three days notice and sue the tenant for up to three times the amount of rent (see Termination and Eviction in Ending the Rental Agreement ).

If a repair needs to be made and it is the landlord's responsibility to make the repair (i.e. the tenant did not cause the damage and the repair is necessary to keep the premisis in a habitable condition or to maintain appliances provided by the landlord) the tenants first step is always to inform the landlord of the problem. None of the tenants rights to have repairs made arise until the landlord has been notified of the problem. As a rule, the notification should be in writing and sent to the landlord via certified mail with a copy retained for the tenant's records. Some repairs, however, may necessitate notifying the landlord in a more prompt manner than that provided by the US Postal Service. In such cases, the tenant may choose to notify the landlord in person or by phone or e-mail. Like verbal rental agreements, verbal notification is recognized by Montana law. A landlord may not refuse to make necessary repairs because notice was not given in writing. However, a tenant who gives verbal notification would be well advised to send the landlord a certified letter documenting the prior notification so as to avoid the possibility of a landlord claiming that notification was, in fact, not given.

Montana law specifies a time period of 14 days for the repair of problems in the unit that materially affect health and safety of the premesis. If the problem results in a case of emergency, the problem must be fixed in 3 days. In the initial notification letter, the tenant may specify that if the repair is not completed within 14 days the rental agreement will terminate in 30 days. In the case of an emergency, the tenant may specify that the rental agreement will terminate immediately if the repair is not completed in 3 days. If the landlord fails to have the necessary repairs made within the proper time period the tenant has a variety of options for having the repair made, if they do not wish to terminate the agreement.

Option 1: Repair & Deduct
If the cost of the repair is less than one month's rent, the tenant may have the repair made, pay for it, and deduct the cost from the next month's rent. The repair must be made by a professional and a copy of the receipt should be included with the next month's rent payment. This method, commonly known as "repair and deduct", may not be used to make repairs costing more than one month's rent. In addition, the tenant may file a Small Claims Court charge against the landlord to recover any damages s/he incurred due to the landlord's negligence.


Option 2: Injuctive Relief
If the cost of the repairs is more than one month's rent, the tenant may seek "injunctive relief" to force the landlord to comply with his/her responibilities to maintain the premisis. To do this, the tenant must file a complaint in the Justice Court specifying the repairs which are necessary and requesting a court order requiring that the landlord have the repairs made in a timely manner. As in option 1 above, the tenant may recover any damages incurred due to the landlord's negligence through the Small Claims Court .


Options 1 and 2 are generally employed by tenants to have minor repairs made that do not affect the delivery of essential services. If the failure of the landlord to make the required repairs results in the interuption or loss of essential services such as heating or running water, the tenant may either utilize option 1 or 2 or pursue one of the following options. It is important to note that in pursuing options 3,4 or 5, the tenant gives up his/her right to pursue options 1 or 2. In all cases, the landlord must first be notified of the problem and be given an adequate amount of time in which to fix it.


Option 3: Obtaining Service
The tenant may obtain reasonable amounts of the service from some other source and deduct the cost of the service from the next month's rent, and continue to do so until the landlord has made the necessary repairs, provided, of course, that the costs do not exceed the amount of rent. For example, if the landlord fails to repair the furnace, resulting in the loss of heat, the tenant, after notifying the landlord of the problem, may purchase a space heater and deduct its cost along with the increased amount of the electricity bill from the next month's rent. In this case, the space heater would belong to the landlord once its cost has been deducted from the rent.


Option 4: Substitute Housing
The tenant may procure substitue housing until such time as the landlord has made the necessary repairs. During this time the tenant is not required to pay rent to the landlord.


Option 5: Diminished Fair Rental Value
The tenant may recover damages from the landlord based on the diminished fair rental value of the unit. The idea here is that if the unit is worth $300 per month when everything is in good working order, it is worth less when everything isn't working. If the running water has stopped working, the unit may only be worth $150 per month. Montana law doesn't specify what diminished fair rental value is in monetary terms for specific situations, so it is up to the tenant and the landlord to work out exactly how diminished the rental value is. If they cannot come to an agreement, the Small Claims Court judge may ultimately decide.


Utilities

The rental agreement should specify which utilities the landlord provides and which the tenant is responsible for. The landlord must provide garbage cans, unless otherwise specified in the rental contract, but you may be required to pay for garbage pick-up.

If the landlord controls the heat, s/he must supply it between October 1 and May 1. If the tenant is responsible for the heating bills, Montana Power cannot shut it off from November 1 through April 1 unless it receives permission from the Public Service Commission.

If you need help paying for your utility bills, apply through the Human Resource Council (see Montana Resource Directory ) for assistance from the "Low Income Energy Assistance Program (LIEAP)" or "Energy Share". LIEAP is designed to help low income individuals or families who cannot afford to pay their full heating bills during the winter, based on family and house size, annual income, and the type of heat you use (electric or gas). Energy Share is a state program, providing emergency assistance in paying power bills for those without the funds to pay their own bills. Assistance is available from October 1 through April 30.


Fire Safety

Be sure your dwelling conforms to fire safety codes. If you are not familiar with general fire prevention practices, consult your local fire department.

Use stoves and fireplaces properly and carefully. Plug electric ranges into an outlet. Do not wire them directly into the wall. Make sure fireplaces and wood stoves have safe, clean chimneys or other outside ventilation sources. Keep combustible materials, such as wood and paper, at least four feet from wood stoves.

Use and maintain smoke detectors. All landlords are required to install a certified smoke detector, at their expense, in each dwelling unit under their control. It is the Tenant's responsibility to properly maintain these detectors (i.e. replacing batteries when necessary and reporting to the Landlord if the detector seems to be malfunctioning). Use ionization or photoelectric smoke detectors, not heat detectors. There should be at least one smoke detector per dwelling unit. The tenant should check to make sure smoke detectors are properly installed, and s/he also might want to install additional smoke detectors as needed. However, if the tenant installs a smoke detectors on the wall, it may become the property of the landlord.

Follow the guidelines below to ensure that your smoke detector is properly placed:

1. A smoke detector's primary function is to awaken sleeping persons and warn them of a dangerous fire. As such, the most important rule for locating a smoke detector is that the detector be between the bedrooms and the rest of the house, but closer to the bedrooms.

2. Place smoke detectors on the ceiling or on a wall six to 12 inches from the ceiling. Never install within six inches of where the wall and the ceiling meet. This is usually dead air space and smoke tends to miss it.

3. Do not place smoke detectors near vents, heating ducts, and other sources of air current which may keep smoke from reaching the detector.

4. Do not place smoke detectors in or adjacent to the kitchen or bathrooms where cooking, steam, etc. might unnecessarily set off the alarm.

5. Avoid placing detectors on a ceiling which is significantly warmer or colder than the rest of the room because a thermal barrier might exist which prevents smoke from entering the smoke detector. This is of primary concern with mobile homes, poorly insulated houses, outside ceilings, and outside walls. If you live in a mobile home, never install the detector on the ceiling or any outside wallsuse an interior wall.

6. For multistory homes, place a detector on each level of the house, preferably at the top of stairwells. Don't forget to put one in the basement.

7. Follow the manufacturer's installment directions carefully.

Smoke detectors are effective life saving alarms, but they save lives and property only if maintained properly. Follow these rules to keep your alarm working.

1. Test your alarm once a month. Some smoke alarms have a "test button." However, this is not always reliable. It may test the electrical circuit only and not the alarm's ability to detect smoke adequately. To test properly, hold a candle six inches under the detector. To test ionization alarms, let the candle burn. To test photoelectric alarms, extinguish the candle and let the smoke drift into the detector. The alarm should sound within 20 seconds. If it does, fan the smoke away to stop the alarm, and leave as is: the alarm is ready.

2. Replace batteries as needed but at least once a year. Keep spares handy.

3. Replace light bulbs in photoelectric detectors as needed. Keep spares handy.


Renter's Insurance

Renters may have property of considerable value in the apartment or house. The landlord's insurance probably will not cover damage which occurs to tenant's property due to fire, theft, broken water pipes, or natural disaster. Thus, tenants should consider purchasing renter's insurance. Renter's insurance is designed to cover only losses of the tenant's property, not the landlord's. Tenant's seeking insurance should call a variety of insurance agents to get the policy that meets their needs for the best price. Yearly premiums are based on the value of the property the tenant is insuring and generally range from $50 on up. If the tenant is a student under age 21, their property may be covered by their family's homeowner policy.


Landlord's Right to Access; Tenant's Right to Privacy
( MCA 70-24-312 , 70-24-410 , 70-24-424 )

Both tenant privacy and landlord access are protected under Montana law. Landlords cannot abuse their right of access, nor can tenants unreasonably withhold consent from the landlord or the landlord's agent to lawfully enter the unit. In particular:

1. The tenant cannot unreasonably deny access to the landlord in order to inspect the premises, make repairs or improvements, supply services, or show the dwelling to prospective tenants, purchasers, workers, contractors, etc.

2. The landlord cannot abuse the right of access to harass the tenant. Except in emergencies or unless it is impracticable to do so, the landlord must give the tenant 24 hours notice (verbal or written) of her/his intent to enter the premises. The landlord can enter only at reasonable times. Notice may be considered impractable if the tenant is absent from the dwelling for an extended period.

3. The landlord can enter the premises without 24 hour notice only: a) in an emergency; b) if s/he has a court order or; c) if the rental agreement contains a provision allowing the landlord access when reasonably necessary in cases where the tenant is absent more than seven days.

4. If the landlord makes an unlawful entry or a lawful entry in an unreasonable manner (such as an entry at an unreasonable time), or makes repeated demands for access which harasses the tenant (for example, giving the tenant a 24 hour notice every day for a week), the tenant may obtain injunctive (court ordered) relief from the Justice Court or terminate the rental agreement ( MCA 70-24-410 ). On the other hand, if a tenant refuses access to the landlord, the landlord may obtain injunctive relief from the Justice Court to force the tenant to allow access or terminate the rental agreement ( MCA 70-24-424 ). In cases of abuse by the landlord or refusal by the tenant of access, the law allows for recovery of actual damages through the Small Claims Court .

5. The tenant may not remove, replace or add a lock to the premises without the written permission of the landlord. If the tenant adds or replaces a lock not supplied by the landlord, then the tenant must provide a key to ensure that the landlord will continue to have the right of access. If the tenant fails to supply a key, then the landlord may either obtain an order from the court or terminate the rental agreement.


Road Maintenance Obligations (Mobile Homes)

The mobile home park landlord must keep common roads within the park in safe condition, including arranging for snow plowing when needed to make the roads passable.


Section 8 (Subsidized) Housing

Landlord Responsibilities (Section 8)
Section 8 landlords are required to maintain their units in accordance with MCA 70-24-303 (see Subsidized Housing ) and with federal Housing Quality Standards. MDOC local agents may perform inspections of Section 8 housing once a year, or in response to a tenant complaint, to insure that all units are meeting the standards. If a defeciency is found the landlord will recieve a deficiency letter stating what the landlord needs to do to bring the unit into compliance and specifying a period of time in which the repairs must be made. If the defect is life threatening, the landlord must correct the problem in 24 hours. After the deficiency has been fixed, the tenant must call the local Section 8 agency to schedule another inspection to verify that the problem has been fixed. The landlord should verify with the local agency that a reinspection has been scheduled. MDOC will not issue a rent check to the landlord until a reinspection has been completed.

In Moderate Rehabilitation units, landlords are responsible for repairing all damages to the unit, even those caused by the tenants. The landlord may, however, seek compensation for damages to the unit caused by the tenant in Civil Court and/or terminate the rental agreement.

Landlords are also reponsible for enforcing all tenant obligations under the lease. It is not the reponsibility of MDOC or their local field agents to ensure tenant compliance with the lease. If the unit is to be occupied by a disabled person, it is also the landlord's responsibility to make any nessecary modifications to the unit though these modifications may be at the tenant's expense.


Tenant Responsibilities (Section 8)

All Section 8 tenants are required to abide by Montana tenant/landlord law in regards to the care

and maintainence of the unit they are renting. Tenants are responsible for correcting any breach of the Housing Quality Standards that were caused by the tenant, within the amount of time specified by MDOC. If the breach is life threatening, the tenant must correct the situation in 24 hours.

In addition to these responsibilities, tenants must supply all information that MDOC, its local agents or HUD determines is necessary for the administration of the program. The family must also provide local Section 8 agents with at least a 30 day written notice if they intend to terminate their rental agreement or a copy of any eviction notice from the owner of the unit. Families are also required to notify their local agents of any change in the composition of the household. No family members may be added to the household without prior consent from MDOC.

Also see Subsidized Housing .

 

Questions?  Comments?  Contact the webmaster ; for more contact information, click here .